Case Study: Advancing to Leadership in Higher Education Without a Master’s Degree
Introduction: Breaking Through Career Barriers in Higher Education
Landing leadership roles in higher education can be challenging, especially without a master’s degree. Our client, an experienced administrative professional, found themselves struggling to move into higher-paying, leadership-track positions despite over five years of progressive experience in academic affairs, student services, and registrar operations. They said:
“I really love the industry, but I cannot seem to get the higher-paying jobs like I used to when I was younger. I’d love to move into a more senior administrative role, but I don’t have a master’s degree, and I feel like that’s holding me back, even though I know I can do the job.”
The client had the drive, background, and skills needed to excel, but their existing resume wasn’t telling the right story. They needed a complete resume overhaul to showcase their leadership, strategic thinking, and industry expertise without being held back by the perceived barrier of not having an advanced degree.
Challenges: What Was Holding Them Back?
After reviewing the client’s existing resume and job targets, we identified several critical challenges:
Outdated Resume Format
The resume didn’t align with modern resume standards and lacked the visual hierarchy and structure needed for quick scanning by both recruiters and ATS systems.
Lack of Quantifiable Achievements
The resume focused on job duties rather than measurable results. It didn’t effectively capture the impact the client had made in their roles, such as process improvements or student success outcomes.
Under-leveraged Leadership Experience
Despite having final sign-off authority, oversight responsibilities, and a history of leading teams, the resume didn’t effectively communicate this experience.
Keyword Gaps
The resume lacked alignment with job description language for titles like Director of Academic Services, Assistant Dean, or Academic Operations Manager. This made it less likely to pass ATS scans and reach human eyes.
Confidence Gap Due to Degree Requirements
The client felt they might not be qualified for leadership roles simply because they lacked a master’s degree, despite years of relevant experience and proven capability.
Our Goals: Repositioning for Leadership Without a Master’s
Together, we identified clear goals for the engagement:
Rebuild the Resume: Create a modern, ATS-friendly resume that clearly conveyed leadership, innovation, and strategic contributions.
Position for Career Mobility: Highlight roles that emphasized strategy, oversight, and academic operations.
Compensate for Degree Barrier: Emphasize hands-on leadership, results, and process ownership to counter the perceived degree gap.
Provide Job Search Support: Educate the client on strategic job searching, including keyword tips and alternate job titles.
The Process: From Overhaul to Impact-Driven Results
1. Discovery & Intake
The client shared a PDF of their current resume, screenshots of three roles they were targeting (Assistant Dean, Registrar, and Academic Program Manager), and insights into their day-to-day work and special projects they led. They also communicated a fast desired deadline to meet the upcoming application deadlines, prompting us to structure this as a fast-tracked engagement.
2. Resume Reconstruction
We didn’t just revise their resume; we rebuilt it from scratch with the following approach:
- Professional Summary: Crafted a confident, leadership-focused summary that clearly conveyed their ability to lead academic operations, improve processes, and collaborate with university stakeholders.
- Leadership Language: Incorporated strong verbs and framing to show initiative, authority, and strategic contributions (e.g., “Spearheaded cross-department collaboration,” “Led accreditation readiness initiatives,” “Oversaw academic data reporting strategy”).
- Impact-Driven Bullets: Rewrote their previous job descriptions to emphasize outcomes. For example:
- “Developed a streamlined transfer credit evaluation process, including an online tool that enabled real-time self-assessment for students, improving transparency and reducing counselor workload by 15%.”
- “Partnered with the database manager to launch a student-facing graduation status tracker, improving retention by 17% and proactively resolving academic and document holds.”
- “Initiated a community clinic partnership strategy to boost enrollment by 23% via tuition credit referrals; program success led to measurable increases in student sign-ups.”
- Metrics & Evidence: Added concrete numbers and results to drive impact, wherever available (e.g., reduced processing errors, increased enrollment, faster turnaround on graduation status).
- Education Framing: Addressed the lack of a master’s degree by emphasizing hands-on leadership, strategic contributions, and cross-functional partnerships, positioning experience as the differentiator.
3. Job Search Strategy & Keyword Guidance
Once the resume was approved, the client asked: “What keywords should I use to search for jobs on Indeed and LinkedIn? I feel like I’m not seeing everything.”
We provided a detailed response suggesting more targeted search terms based on job titles and functions, including:
- Student Enrollment
- Academic Operations
- Academic Services Manager
- Student Registration Services
- Director of Registrar Services
- Academic Planning
- Assistant Director / Assistant Dean of Student Affairs
We also recommended using Google Jobs as an aggregator for roles posted across multiple platforms and advised refining filters on Indeed/LinkedIn to better identify remote roles or state-based opportunities.
Deliverables: All the Resources Needed to Land More Interviews
- Rewritten, ATS-friendly resume for higher education leadership roles.
- Personalized impact statements with metrics and keywords.
- Fast turnaround (delivered within 3 business days).
- Two rounds of revisions (with yellow highlights for collaborative completion).
- Bonus support: job search keyword coaching and Google Jobs tip.
Results: Immediate Traction and Career Momentum
Resume Delivered On Time
We delivered the final resume ahead of the deadline. The client responded enthusiastically: “I think it looks great! I can add those fillers, of course. Thank you so much!”
Immediate Traction
Shortly after receiving the final draft, the client landed their first interview, a promising sign after months of limited activity.
“ProTouch Careers did an excellent job! I’m proud to say that I’ve already had my first interview and I’m very excited! I definitely recommend their services.”
The resume not only opened doors but helped rebuild confidence, demonstrating that experience, leadership, and results can outweigh degree requirements when positioned correctly.
Key Takeaways: Lessons for Career Changers
Experience Can Speak Louder Than Degrees: With the right language and structure, candidates without traditional academic credentials can still win leadership roles.
Tailored Materials Drive Interviews: A generic resume won’t cut it in a competitive field. Rebuilding from scratch using relevant job descriptions is essential.
Small Shifts Create Big Visibility: Strategic keyword use and reframing contributions from “tasks” to “impact” helped the client stand out.
Confidence Comes from Clarity: Sometimes, the biggest shift isn’t in the resume, it’s in how the client sees themselves after reading it.
Ready to Elevate Your Career?
This project is a strong example of how tailored, strategic resume writing can reposition an experienced professional for the next chapter of their career, even when credentials don’t match job listings word-for-word. Through focused storytelling, collaborative feedback, and keyword-driven strategy, the client was able to regain momentum and take concrete steps toward a leadership role in the field they love. You can, too!
Need help writing a resume that positions you for leadership? Check out our packages.
Contact Us
Have some questions before getting started?
If you have any questions about the right package for you, our services, or the process, please submit the form.
